Presto vs All American: Which Pressure Canner Should You Buy?
Both are safe, both are sold everywhere, and both have been canning green beans for generations. They differ in price, weight and what you maintain.
Buy the Presto 23-Quart if you want a light, affordable canner and don't mind replacing a gasket and testing the gauge; buy the All American 921 if you'll can for decades and want no gasket and no yearly testing.
| Presto 23-Quart (01781) | All American 921 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | About $190 | About $450 |
| Holds | 7 qt or 20 pt | 7 qt or 18 pt |
| Seal | Rubber sealing ring | Machined metal to metal |
| Pressure control | Dial gauge (weight optional) | Weighted regulator plus dial |
| Yearly gauge test | Yes | Not needed for the weight |
| Metal | Thin aluminum | Thick cast aluminum |
| Induction | No (01784 version yes) | No |
| Company | National Presto, Eau Claire, Wis. | Wisconsin Aluminum Foundry, Manitowoc, Wis. |
Gasket vs metal seal
Presto's lid seals with a rubber ring that hardens and stretches over time; you replace it, along with the small overpressure plug, every few seasons. They're cheap and easy to find. The All American's lid and pot are machined to seal metal to metal under wing-nut clamps, so there's nothing to replace. You do need to keep the beveled edge lightly greased.
Dial vs weight
The Presto is built around a dial gauge, which lets you process at exactly 11, 12, 13 or 14 pounds depending on altitude, but it must be tested every year. The All American's weight rocks at 5, 10 or 15 pounds and needs no testing. Above 1,000 feet, it means processing at 15 pounds. More on that in dial vs weighted gauge.
Day to day
The Presto heats and cools faster and is far easier to lift and wash. The All American's thick walls hold heat, so cycles take longer, and the heavy lid and clamps take getting used to. Both hold seven quarts.
Which to buy
- Presto if you can a few times a year, want to spend under $200, need induction (the 01784), or lifting weight matters.
- All American if you can every year and want a canner to hand down, live far from gauge testing, or are tired of replacing gaskets.
Presto 23-Quart Pressure Canner and Cooker (01781)
- Price
- About $190
- Holds
- 7 quarts or 20 pints
- Control
- Dial gauge
- Heat
- Gas, coil, smooth-top
All American 21.5-Quart Pressure Canner (921)
- Price
- About $450
- Holds
- 7 quarts or 18 pints
- Control
- Weight and dial gauge
- Heat
- Gas, coil (not induction)
Questions
Is All American better than Presto?
It's more durable and needs less upkeep, not safer. Both process food safely when used correctly.
Can I put a weight on a Presto?
Yes. Presto sells a 3-piece regulator that rocks at 5, 10 or 15 pounds for its canners.