Independent reviews of pressure, water-bath and steam canners, checked against USDA canning guidanceHow we make money
Guide

Why Canning Jars Don't Seal (and What to Do)

Most failed seals come down to the rim, the headspace or how the canner was cooled.

Canning jars usually fail to seal because of food on the rim, the wrong headspace, a nicked rim or a lid that was overtightened or reused; reprocess unsealed jars within 24 hours with a new lid, or refrigerate them and eat the food within a few days.

Updated November 16, 2026 · By the editors of Home Canning Report · We earn from qualifying purchases

How to tell

After the jars cool 12 to 24 hours, press the center of each lid. A sealed lid is curved down and doesn't flex. Remove the band and gently lift the jar by the lid edge; a good seal holds.

Common causes

  • Food, syrup or grease on the rim. Wipe rims with a clean damp cloth before lidding.
  • Wrong headspace. See the headspace chart.
  • Nicked or chipped jar rims.
  • Reused flat lids, whose sealing compound is already used.
  • Bands too tight (air can't escape) or too loose. Tighten to fingertip-tight.
  • Air bubbles not removed.

Liquid loss (siphoning)

In pressure canners, siphoning often comes from fast pressure changes: forcing the canner to cool, removing the weight too early, or fluctuating pressure during processing. Let the canner return to zero on its own, wait 10 minutes after removing the weight before opening, and hold pressure steady. In a water bath, turning off the heat and waiting 5 minutes before lifting jars helps. Sealed jars that lost some liquid are safe to store, though food above the liquid may darken.

What to do with unsealed jars

  1. Within 24 hours: remove the lid, check the rim, put on a new lid and reprocess for the full time in the recipe.
  2. Or refrigerate and use within a few days.
  3. Or freeze, if the food freezes well and there's room for expansion.

Questions

Can I just tighten the band after processing?

No. Retightening after processing doesn't create a seal and can break one that's forming.

How long can an unsealed jar sit before reprocessing?

Reprocess within 24 hours, per USDA guidance, or refrigerate it.

Keep reading