Independent reviews of pressure, water-bath and steam canners, checked against USDA canning guidanceHow we make money
Review

All American 21.5-Quart Pressure Canner (921) Review

The heavy, gasketless canner people hand down: cast aluminum, made in Wisconsin, with a weight that rocks at 5, 10 or 15 pounds.

The All American 921 is the pressure canner to buy once and keep for life: no gasket, a weighted regulator that needs no yearly testing, and room for seven quarts or 18 pints, for about $450.

Updated November 16, 2026 · By the editors of Home Canning Report · We earn from qualifying purchases

Price
About $450
Holds
7 quarts or 18 pints
Control
Weight and dial gauge
Heat
Gas, coil (not induction)

Good

  • Metal-to-metal seal, no gasket to replace
  • Rocking weight at 5, 10 or 15 lb; no yearly gauge testing
  • 18 pints in two layers
  • Made in Wisconsin and widely handed down

Not so good

  • About $450, more than twice a Presto
  • Heavy; slow to heat and cool
  • Above 1,000 ft you process at 15 lb
  • Not for induction

Who it's for

Buy it if you can every year and want the most durable canner, or you live where gauge testing is hard to find.

Skip it if you want the lowest price, you cook on induction, or lifting a heavy pot is a problem.

How All Americans are built

All American canners are made by Wisconsin Aluminum Foundry in Manitowoc, Wisconsin, from thick cast aluminum. The lid and pot are machined so they seal metal to metal, held down by wing-nut clamps around the rim. There's no rubber gasket to replace; you wipe a thin film of petroleum jelly or olive oil on the beveled edge so the lid seats and comes off easily.

Each one has two pressure controls. The regulator weight on the vent pipe rocks at 5, 10 or 15 pounds and is what you go by. The geared dial gauge is a reference. Because the weight controls pressure, you don't need yearly gauge testing to can safely, though a dial that disagrees with the weight is worth checking.

Why the 921 is the one most people pick

The 921 is the smallest All American that double-stacks pints, which is why it's the most popular size. Seven quarts in one layer or 18 pints in two covers most home batches. A bushel of green beans makes 12 to 20 quarts, according to USDA, so even the 921 takes two or three loads for one. If you regularly can more than that in a day, the 930 adds a second layer of quarts.

The trade-offs

Thick metal means slow heating and slow cooling, so a full cycle takes longer than with a Presto. The lid is heavy and the clamps take a minute to tighten evenly. The weighted gauge only does 5, 10 or 15 pounds, so above 1,000 feet you process at 15 pounds rather than the 11 to 14 a dial gauge would use. That's safe; it just runs hotter than needed, which can soften some vegetables.

All Americans are aluminum, so they don't work on induction. For glass-top ranges, check your range manual: a loaded 921 is heavy, and some range makers limit pot weight.

Questions

Is the All American 921 worth the extra money over a Presto?

If you'll can for years, often yes: there's no gasket to replace and no yearly gauge test. If you can a few times a year, a Presto does the same job for less. See Presto vs All American.

How many pint jars fit in the All American 921?

Eighteen regular-mouth pints in two layers, according to All American. Wide-mouth pints fit fewer.

Can I use the 921 on a glass-top stove?

Check your range manual first. Some range makers limit pot weight, and a full 921 is heavy.

Keep reading